A Nobel Prize-winning German novelist—a former SS soldier, no less—accuses the state of Israel of seeking to exterminate an entire people, and the literary republic yawns. But when Israel bars its accuser from entering the country, because ex-Nazis have no place in the Jewish state, the cries of "bullying" and "censorship" nearly drown out the original accusation.
An Open Letter to Günter GrassDaniel Johnson, New York Sun. After 60 years, was it Grass's conscience that prompted him to admit that he belonged to the Waffen SS? "The absence of contrition . . . excludes that possibility. I am afraid that the most cynical motive is also the most plausible: You had an autobiography to sell." (2006; Part II is here.) SAVE
The New PrejudiceHoward Jacobson, Independent. By brute consensus, now, Israel is the proof that Jews did not adequately learn the lesson of the Holocaust. SAVE
Anti-Zionism and Anti-SemitismRobert Wistrich, Jewish Political Studies Review. Anti-Zionism uses stereotypes concerning the "Jewish/Zionist lobby," Israeli/Jewish "criminality," and Sharonist "warmongering" that are fundamentally manipulative and anti-Semitic. SAVE
Antiquity washes away the immediacy of historical pain and injustice. Our ability to feel suffering is indexed directly to its epoch: the more remote, the more detached we are. Museums play on this—pander to this—and to our forgetfulness. History is softened, elided, or erased.
The Last Jews of LibyaDavid Gerbi, Foreign Policy. Gerbi, a Libyan Jewish exile in Rome, saw the Arab Spring as a chance, finally, to rebuild a crumbling Tripoli synagogue. He hoped too soon. SAVE
The Jews of IslamBernard Lewis, Princeton University Press. In one stereotype, past Muslim-Jewish relations look like America, only better; in the other, they look like Hitler's Germany, only worse. Both have elements of truth. SAVE
A look inside three of the twentieth century's most interesting careers in architecture: the world-renowned Israeli Moshe Safdie, on the verge of shutting down the office he opened in Jerusalem in 1970; the Polish-born, polarizing Daniel Libeskind, now at work on rebuilding New York's World Trade Center; and the mythic postwar master Louis Kahn.
Standing at Sinai, "All the people were seeing the thunder" (Exodus 20:15), seeing the sounds. The word "revelation" would be somewhat misleading, since nothing was unveiled: The mountain was wreathed in cloud and smoke.
Change of HeartEsti Ahronovitz, Haaretz. Why isn't Heschel better known in Israel? "Because here," says Dror Bondi, "another God rules." SAVE
Prophetic WitnessEdward K. Kaplan, Samuel H. Dresner, Yale University Press. When Heschel made his powerful 1957 speech, he was assailed on the spot by Yitzhak Tabenkin, venerable keeper of Labor Zionism's ideological flame. SAVE
After 60 years of publishing and recording, seventysomething Leonard Cohen has something else to say; and, lo and behold, the "Camp"—the Bergen-Belsen of the remembered newsreels of his childhood—comes up. He also gets the "Eye"—Jerusalem's Eye of the Needle—in there, a Jewish metaphor from the Talmud and the New Testament.
Going HomeLeonard Cohen, New Yorker. "I love to speak with Leonard / He's a sportsman and a shepherd / He's a lazy bastard / Living in a suit" (from the new album). SAVE
The Jewish MonkLarry Rohter, New York Times. How does Cohen, who keeps the Sabbath even while on tour, square that faith with his continued practice of Zen? "Allen Ginsberg asked me the same question many years ago . . ." SAVE
Retrieving A.M. KleinAllan Nadler, Jewish Ideas Daily. Leonard Cohen's elegiac ballad, "To a Teacher," was dedicated to the vastly prolific (but now all but forgotten) Canadian poet A.M. Klein. SAVE
Sacha Baron Cohen Never ForgetsSteve Sailer. Taki's. The comedian's four main characters have been parodies of present or past foes of the Jews. At this rate, he might even get around to making a movie mocking the Amalekites. SAVE
Wadiya Doin’?J. Hoberman. Tablet. Chaplin's Great Dictator ends with an anti-fascist speech; Sacha Baron Cohen's Dictator breaks the proscenium to make a blunt political statement—about the inequities of American society. SAVE
A Serious ManJoseph Epstein. New Criterion. One day Hilton Kramer appeared to drop off his copy in person at the New Leader offices. The editor asked him if he knew anyone who was looking for a job. "Actually, I do," he said. "Me.". SAVE
Search on a CentennialBen Sales. JTA. One hundred years ago, Yosef Haim Brenner sold a pair of suspenders to fund the publication of S.Y. Agnon's first book—copies of which are now actively sought after. SAVE
Is There Such a Thing as Jewish Fiction?Moment. Howard Jacobson, Geraldine Brooks, A.B. Yehoshua, Shalom Auslander, Walter Mosley, Etgar Keret, André Aciman, Nathan Englander, Nadia Kalman, and others answer. SAVE
Of making Jewish music there is no end, but how many contemporary composers of distinguished work in this genre have been featured on From the Top, National Public Radio's program about exceptional young musicians? Jeremiah Klarman, age thirteen when he appeared on the NPR show, may be the sole exception. Now seventeen, with a demonstrated mastery of styles from classical to klezmer, and with chamber, orchestral, and pop compositions under his belt, Klarman has turned his lavish and protean talents to choral music. A premier of his latest work, the cantata Hallel, Shir v'Or ("Praise, Song, and Light"), drawing largely on well-known verses from the book of Psalms, took place in late December at Temple Emanuel in Newton, Mass. Performed by the Zamir Chorale of Boston under the direction of Joshua R. Jacobson, it culminates in a room-rocking, soul-lifting Halleluyah! for chorus and orchestra.
A Day in the LifeRichard Dyer, Boston Globe. Jeremiah Klarman spends an afternoon in 2006 with the "moved, impressed, and amazed" composer Osvald Golijov. SAVE
Third in a series on landmarks in American Jewish literature
In American literature, the critic Leslie Fiedler once quipped, nothing succeeds like failure. But among American Jewish writers, something like the reverse is closer to the truth: for many of their fictional characters, nothing fails so miserably as success. Nowhere is this seen more clearly than in The Rise of David Levinsky(1917), the first classic of Jewish fiction in America.
Hayim Nahman Bialik (1873–1934) was the poet of Jewish national rebirth and a leading light of cultural Zionism. To be more precise, he was a power station. Composing poems, writing essays, founding journals, raising up the sparks of Israel's past, Bialik became an essential source of energy for Jewish cultural revival.
It was bound to happen. Abraham Sutzkever, born July 15, 1913, in Smorgon, Lithuania, one of the great poets of the twentieth century and the last towering figure of modern Yiddish literature, died this Wednesday, January 20, in Tel Aviv, where he had lived since 1947. A descendant of rabbis, Sutzkever applied to the writing of poetry the standards of refinement that his ancestors had practiced in obedience to Jewish religious law. During World War II, when he was herded into the ghetto with the rest of Vilna Jewry, he determinedly continued composing, persuaded that "the angel of poetry" protects the creator of timeless—but only of truly timeless—work.